by Tinker » Tue Mar 08, 2011 2:56 pm
Most people don't understand that what happened wasn't Communism. This goes doubly for those who use, "Real Communism was never tried.", as a sneer. Real Communism is a complete and total lack of government whatsoever. It's a society where everyone is willing to give whatever is needed to whoever needs it, if it's within their power to do so. Having lived for short times in temporary communistic settings, I have observed that if people behave in this way, every individual is actually wealthier coming out than they were going in. But it only works if everyone participates. When there are parasites on the collective, it breaks down and you get back into competitive paradigms very rapidly. This is why in my times of experiencing this, it is always temporary, because the wealth was facilitated in the normal every day world.
There are some who will only work if there is some distinct immediate profit motive for them. There are others who will work simply because something needs to be done. The second type of person would be fine under Communism. The first type of person would destroy it.
Though I think the point about Marx and revolutionary cycles is interesting. If what is happening right now erodes faith in the Capitalist system, we may very well see the rise of what I'll call Craigslist Communism.
The canary didn't die because this mine is dangerous, it died because it's lazy and wasn't raised with a proper work ethic.